BENEFIT COSMETICS they're real! lengthening beyond mascara FULL SIZE 8.5 g Net wt. 0.3 oz. BLACK

Product Information

DW Used to love it Something changed! It snugged and flakes now. Raccoon eyes. I've switched to other Benefit mascaras which I prefer now. Bad girl and Curl. Charlotte1238 Messy really wanted to like this, it smudges really easily and transfers onto my eyelids. Had people constantly pointing this out to me, replaced with a cheaper drugstore one for half the price that is much better which was frustrating as it was only a week old

However, with several varieties on offer, all claiming to add more volume, length, definition and general flutter than the last, how is one supposed to narrow it down? That’s where we come in! Each one of these Benefit mascaras was bought using our own money – none were gifted and Benefit didn’t have any input in this list. These are real-world results, used on natural lashes. It provided unrivalled volume whilst also adding length and we found one coat was enough, but it was still possible to add a second coat.

Designed to fan out lashes, add volume, and “multiply the look of lashes”, this new mascara uses what Benefit calls its Full-Flex Fiber Brush. This brush has a 40-degree curve engineered to lift the roots and cover all lashes. Even those in the corners. Case in point: Aldi's latest lash builder, Too Legit Mascara, looks suspiciously similar Benefit's They're Real - and when we say similar, we mean it's a dead ringer dupe and we have a lot of questions. Where do we even start? We LOVE Benefit’s Roller Lash mascara and it was a clear winner from the very first use. Perfect coverage, curls that out-delivered even our best eyelash curler efforts, length, definition, long-lasting colour…we could go on about this Benefit mascara for weeks.

JFDa Good brush I like this mascara as the brush is a good shape for my sparse eyelashes. Pity it isn't in brown. WANT MORE GROUP TESTS? Best MAC mascara | Best No7 foundation | Best Charlotte Tilbury foundation | Best MAC foundation | Best mascara | Best drugstore mascaraIt features a plastic curved wand that was super easy to get right down to the roots. It really only needs one coat but it still layered well for high-drama, evening looks. UPDATE: The Benefit Advent Calendar 2023 is now on sale and it contains all of the best benefit mascaras featured in this guide. With the amount of mascaras out there, it would be silly to assume that there would never be two similar wands in this world - after all, there are only so many variations of brushes and formulas one can create. In our real-world tests, we found this Benefit mascara needed a few layers to really get the dramatic effect we like, although it does build and layer well. On the plus side, it was easy to remove, something that can be a deal-breaker when you just want to fall into bed at night, and reduce damage to your lashes and sensitive skin around your eyes. We didn’t think that another Benefit mascara, or any mascara for that matter, could rival the Roller Lash and while it fell slightly short, the new Benefit Fan Fest very nearly managed it.